Rachel's Table

Where Hemingway Ate (and Drank)

While in Key West last month, I visited the home of Ernest Hemingway, famed author and American icon.

When Hemingway lived on the property, he shared it with his wife (at the time) Pauline and their two young sons, Patrick and Gregory. According to Patrick, his childhood at the Key West house was magical. Magic hung in the warm air the day I visited.

Grand front entrance

Grand front entrance

The house is the largest single family home on the island and still functions as a residence…to 45 cats. Legend says these cats are all descendants of Hemingway’s six-toed cat named Snowball, a gift from a ship’s captain. Some accounts say Hemingway’s pet of choice while living on Key West was peacocks, not cats. Either way, Hemingway owned several felines throughout his lifetime, stating, A cat has absolute emotional honesty: human beings, for one reason or another, may hide their feelings, but a cat does not.” 

Hemingway in Cuba with Patrick and Gregory and some feline friends

Hemingway in Cuba with Patrick and Gregory and some feline friends Source

It’s hard to believe the cats currently roaming Hemingway’s house aren’t the great-great grand kitties of Snowball, since half the cats I saw have Snowball’s trademark six toes. Their little paws resemble mittens.

Snowball's great grandkitten, perhaps?

Snowball’s great grandkitten, perhaps?

Kitten Mittens

Kitten Mittens (It’s Always Sunny, anyone?)

This cat snuggled in my lap and like a tourist with a fanny pack, I gave the thumbs up. Even so, this was a good moment.

This cat snuggled in my lap and like a tourist with a fanny pack, I gave the thumbs up. Even so, this was a good moment.

I could hardly tear myself away from the cats as they wandered through the trees and lounged on the lush grass. But I did manage to go inside for a little while. The Hemingway House is lovely with first and second floor verandas, shuttered windows and high ceilings. Traditional in its layout, the house has a center hallway with a dining room to the right, living room to the left, and a small kitchen toward the back.

The first floor veranda, right off the living room

The first floor veranda with tall shutters

Hemingway's king-sized bed, complete with kitten taking a snooze

Hemingway’s king-sized bed, complete with kitten taking a snooze

The master bathroom, the only second floor bathroom in Key West until after 1944

The master bathroom (a rain water cistern was on the roof right above the bathroom, because Key West did not have running water at the time)

Lighthouse view from the second floor veranda

Lighthouse view from the second floor veranda

The grounds surrounding the house are both calming and invigorating, complete with towering palm trees and secret nooks carved among the greenery.  The pool, which set Hemingway back an unheard of $20,000 in 1933, is huge even by today’s standards. Because Key West did not have running water when the pool was constructed, the builders drilled down through hard coral to hit salt water, then pumped the water up and into the pool. Hemingway was so fed up with the endless costs of the pool, he threw a penny down at his wife’s feet and cried, Pauline, you’ve spent all but my last penny, so you might as well have that!”  

Naturally, Pauline had the penny embedded into the concrete patio.

The infamous penny

The infamous penny

A peaceful spot to hide away from the world

A peaceful spot to hide away from the world with the pool in the background

The controversial pool in all it's glory

The controversial pool in all it’s glory

A replica of the main house for the cats with a fat cat lounging out front

A replica of the main house for the cats with a fat cat lounging out front

The best part of the house (besides the cats) is Hemingway’s study, which is above the coach house, right by the pool. Hemingway’s Royal brand portable typewriter sits on a dark, heavy table and his books perch on white shelves under the watchful gaze of several animal busts. Hemingway wrote seven novels in this room, including A Farewell to Arms and Death in the Afternoon.

Hemingway's lovely study

Hemingway’s lovely study

Hemingway's typewriter

Hemingway’s typewriter

Another view

Another view

A suitcase with Hemingway's initials

A suitcase with Hemingway’s initials

Hemingway stayed in Key West off and on for 12 years and enjoyed a productive but playful life. It wouldn’t be hard to feel creative in such a place; the house felt expansive yet secluded, cozy yet full of light and air.

When asked about his days on Key West Hemingway said, “It’s the best place I’ve ever been anytime, anywhere…flowers, tamarind trees, guava trees, coconut palms…Got tight last night on absinthe and did knife tricks.”

So now we know what Hemingway drank on Key West, but what did he eat?  The Hemingways enjoyed hosting dinner parties with seafood, so plentiful on the island, as the star ingredient. In a beloved food quote, Hemingway extols the transformative nature of an oyster: “As I ate the oysters with their strong taste of the sea and their faint metallic taste that the cold white wine washed away, leaving only the sea taste and the succulent texture, and as I drank their cold liquid from each shell and washed it down with the crisp taste of the wine, I lost the empty feeling and began to be happy, and to make plans.”

Good food always inspires me to make plans. Maybe Hemingway and I are kindred spirits.

Hemingway’s Ropa Vieja

As I left Hemingway’s home, I was struck by the contrast in his nature. His love for the delicate flavor of a single oyster, his affinity for a sweet kitten, his appreciation for flowering trees juxtaposed with his appetite for more “manly” pursuits like big game hunting, fishing, boxing, drinking, and knife tricks.

Hemingway wrote in the morning surrounded by his beautiful landscape and frequented Sloppy Joe’s bar every afternoon. While there, he may have eaten Ropa Vieja, meaning “old clothes,” a tangy, spicy Cuban dish robust and interesting enough to satisfy both a refined palate and a ravenous appetite.


1/4 cup vegetable oil

2 pounds flank steak, cut into 1 inch strips (make sure to cut against the grain of the meat)

Kosher salt

Freshly ground black pepper

1 medium sweet onion, thinly sliced

1 yellow bell pepper, thickly sliced

1 green bell pepper, thinly sliced

2 ounces tomato paste

1 tablespoon cumin

4 sprigs fresh thyme

1 tablespoon dried oregano

6 cloves garlic, finely choppped

1 bay leaf

1 dried Jamaican Hot Chocolate Pepper, slightly crushed (This pepper was from my Peppermeister stash. If you don’t have this type of pepper, no worries. Just substitute any kind of dried pepper, red pepper flakes or a fresh jalapeno here.)

This pepper is HOT and infused the whole dish with a pleasant heat

This pepper is HOT and infused the whole dish with a pleasant heat

1/2 cup dry white wine

2 cups beef stock

1 pint jar whole peeled tomatoes, crushed ( or 1 16-ounce can stewed or diced tomatoes)

1/2 cup pitted green olives, halved

These olives may not be local but I did buy them at the local Amish cheese shop

These olives may not be local but I did buy them at the local Amish cheese shop

1 tablespoon white wine vinegar

1/4 cup cilantro, chopped

Cooked white rice for serving

Getting all the ingredients prepped ahead of time really helped this dish come together quickly (besides the 3 hour simmer time)

Getting all the ingredients prepped ahead of time really helped this dish come together quickly (besides the 3 hour simmer time)

Season flank steak generously with salt and pepper. Heat oil in dutch oven over medium-high heat until shimmering (get it as hot as you can). Working in batches, cook the steak on both sides until browned, about 6 minutes. Transfer to a bowl. Add onion and bell peppers. Cook until soft, about 5 minutes. Add tomato paste, cumin, thyme sprigs, oregano, garlic, bay leaf, and Jamaican Hot Chocolate Pepper. Cook until well combined, about 3 minutes.

Smelling so good right about now!

Smelling so good right about now!

Add tomatoes, beef stock, and flank steak to the pot. Bring to a boil. Turn heat to medium low and simmer, covered, for 3 hours, or until the steak is very tender. Remove steak and shred with a fork. Return meat to the pot with the olives and vinegar. Cook, uncovered, until slightly thickened, about 30 minutes.

Tangy, spicy, briny goodness

Tangy, spicy, briny goodness

Taste for seasoning and add salt if necessary (those olives add a nice briny saltiness). Fish out the bay leaf and thyme sprigs. Place a scoop of white rice in bowls and top with the Ropa Vieja. Garnish with cilantro just before serving.

(Next time I might just throw everything but the olives and vinegar in a crock pot for 8 hours on low, and add the olives and vinegar during the last half hour of cooking.)

A Cuban dish fit for an American icon

A Cuban dish fit for an American icon


  1. I couldn’t love this post more. We are reading Hemingway for my intro. to lit class right now. I had no idea about all the six-toed cats. (laughed at the Always Sunny reference, god I LOVE that show!) Seeing all those photos makes me want to go down there one day, it looks heavenly.

    • This recipe is delish! And I’m excited to see how it turns out in the crock pot. I think you could even use a less expensive cut of meat, too. If you make it, let me know how it turns out!

  2. Oh man, does THAT bring back memories. It’s been a few years since I’ve last been to Key West and visited Hemingway’s pad. I remember that pool story fondly, as well as his study. Interestingly, I think I would have a different perspective if I visited now. Back then, I was only a English Lit grad who had read a bunch of his books, so I looked on it as a fan would. Now, I am an aspiring writer, so I believe I would see it with different eyes. More as a kindred spirit or a study of the master.

    That recipe looks fantastic. And no mushrooms! Yay!! 😉

    • This recipe is GOOD, Misty. And you could even throw everything in the crock pot if you’re so inclined.

      I felt like I was a fan and a kindred spirit. I was a big fan of the cats, though. Like they were little celebrities.

      Next time you go to Key West, you must visit again. Such a fun way to spend a morning.

  3. This post is so chock full ‘o goodness I don’t know where to start! Truly excellent post – you are as wonderful a writer / reporter as you are a chef!

    It’s funny, but I’ve never thought about this: When they turn someone’s house into a museum, there’s plenty of merit to it, but it also seems like such a waste… Look at that pool!

    And who, dare I ask, has to clean up after all of those ‘honest’ cats?


    P.P.S. – I want to cement Peppermeister’s last penny in our patio, but I already spent it on bacon.

    • Chef? Writer? I heart you, Jules.

      They have an entire staff to take care of the kittens. The museum was just under investigation for keeping animals on the property with out the proper licensing or something. They won and are now deemed fit to keep 45 cats.

      You are right about that pool! It was fantastic. Such a pretty spot.

      Somehow I think Peppermeister would approve of your last penny spending choice.

  4. What a fantastic post! I visited Key West when I was maybe 22 and at a very dark place in my life. I’d like to go back now. I never got to take the tour of the Hemingway house so I thank you for writing it up. Great photos. I love his study and the little hidden place by the pool. And, of course, the six-toed cats.

  5. When I was in Paris I would go to Hemingway’s favorite bar, Harry’s, and sit where he sat and drink and look out the window and think interesting thoughts.

  6. Nice post but is it too weird that the cats totally freak me out? Even the kitten mittens, it’s like there’s an extra toe in the photo! I’ll just think about key lime pie … pie makes everything better. Jules has bacon chocolate pie. And Uncle Jesse will save me from the cats, right?? RIGHT???!

  7. I love cats! And six toed cats are amazing. I have to admit the cats distracted me from your recipe so I will have to revisit when I calm down.

    kitten mittens! Yes!

  8. Le Clown

    Snowball’s story is quite something… Even Hemingway’s cats (and their descendants) were known to have some of his machismo…
    Le Clown

      • Le Clown,

        From what I hear, yes, SHE got around. But how can we be 100% sure? I’ve also heard that Hemingway had many, many cats at his home in Cuba, not in Key West. We may just be the victims of smart story-telling and the wheel of tourism. Either way, visiting Hemingway’s home and cats was an inspiring experience.


  9. Pingback: Pi Day Pie Winner! | JM Randolph, accidentalstepmom

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: